Monday 10 February 2014

Mainstreaming shame


We’ve all grown up hearing about the stratospheric ideals of ‘unity in diversity’ and ‘Incredible India’ but hardly few of us actually embrace it in its true spirit. We have been calling South Indians as Madrassis and North Easterners as Cheeni for a long while now. We consider ourselves as living in that imaginary cocoon wherein only North India is the heartland and the rest is a foreign land. This mental construct of ours is deplorable. On the contrary, on a dinner table, we are also deeply unsettled with the word that sounds like RACISM. We take it rather personally when an Australian beats up an Indian or when David Cameroon visits Amritsar and doesn’t apologize for the Jalianwala bagh massacre. What does one call that in plain English? Hypocrisy. We Indians are hypocrites.

Recently, the death of a young Arunachal guy named Nido Tania and rape of a Manipuri girl in the capital have spurred the double standard issues that we have. Why are the north easterners not given their due? Why are they treated like foreigners in their own country? Why are boorish comments on their hair style and dressing sense so common? The problem is much deeper than it seems on the surface. Right from the elementary level, the school curriculum doesn’t include much about the north east. It is only at the exam time when mothers make their kids mug up the capitals and dance forms of these seven states. Children are not given even the slightest of knowledge about anthropology which could make them cognizant of the fact that it is just the face of a mongoloid race which makes them that way but in spirit, they are still the same as any other Indian. There is also no interaction among the students of the north east and the rest of India that can possibly reduce the strangeness between them which could aggravate into aloofness in the future.


A lot has been said about ‘mainstreaming’ the north east so that they can be active participants in the growth process of India but what has actually been done? The students of the north east are driven by the lack of opportunities for higher education and jobs to the mainland of India where they have no option but to face the feeling of being an ‘outsider’. Delhi is in fact a mini India and thus rightly a melting pot. But what infuriates me is the fact that Delhiites are not receptive and welcoming enough to people from other states. There are some folks who are just six feet from the edge and they vent it out on other people who are already feeling like ‘outsiders’. Yes, the north easterners dress differently and they talk differently but aren’t we supposed to respect that? They own Delhi as much as we do.

Those seven sisters have a border with the foreign countries, some of whom are aggressive too. People there face competition from the infiltrators from Bangladesh and others just because the Indian government hasn’t been able to stop infiltration in all these decades since independence. Trafficking of drugs is a normal issue there. Connectivity still remains a humongous problem as these seven states are connected to the mainland only through the chicken corridor which if closed, would cut the northeast from India. If this was already not enough, the Kokrajhar incidents happen too. After all this, the question remains, have we after all, given the north east as much attention as we should have? Answer to this question also lies in the difference of reaction of the Indian government to the fast that Irom Sharmila is sitting on since 14 years to repeal the Armed Forces Special Protection Act(AFSPA) and Anna Hazare’s fast for anti corruption bill. I can bet if Irom Sharmila was doing this fast in Delhi, even the media would cover it well. What to talk of a fast if cognizance is not taken of the different time zone that our North Eastern region is in. There is a difference of about 2 hours between IST and the time standard that NE should have. This deprives them of the daylight hours which could be used productively and also distances them further from the happenings in the mainland of India. Just imagine about the prime time at 9 news which comes here at 9 pm in the night would actually come at 11pm in  Arunachal. Enough sensitivity has not been shown to their plights and we talk of ‘mainstreaming’ them. Such a sham!

And if it were not for Digboi, Naharkatia and the gas pipeline from the north east, can we think of our energy demands being fulfilled? Or can we think of India without the Brahmaputra or the Manas wildlife sanctuary? The point is that north east is way too important for us to ignore and its people are our brethren. I say, exemplary punishment must be given to the people who mistreat them and immediate actions should be taken. Simultaneously, the mindset of the people needs to be changed and the children should be made more sensitive about the diversity that India possesses. It's time that India  showcases how ‘incredible’ it actually is.

7 comments:

  1. There were such large scale protests against discrimination of South African students in Delhi after the Somnath Bharti incident in south Delhi. Without undermining their case, I fail to understand why are there no voices outside the northeast community condemning incidents of racism against people of India’s northeast?
    Having said that, you have come up with a very well articulated write up this time and that too on a current issue that has hit a chord with the people of the capital. Keep it up!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Somnath Bharti made a generalized statement while alleging that "these african people" do "such things"(prostitution and drugs etc) but he forgot to realize that if these ugandan women were in fact prostitutes, their clients were Indians! Definitely, the actions of this minister must have triggered a retaliation from the foreign ministries of the african countries and some silent consoling must have been done by Mr Salman Khurshid.

      leave apart Somnath Bharti,lets talk about Kumar Vishwas, who made comments on the nurses of the south, saying that they were dark.
      if such observations come from the political class, what can we expect off they aam aadmi?

      sensitization is the only way out.
      the NE people raise their voices because they consider themselves( and they indeed are) as Indians. if they are not heard, how can the africans even think of revolting, knowing that they are standing on a foreign land?

      india needs to be more welcoming to foreigners and we must respect them! India can not become a SUPERPOWER of the 21st century without respecting its own people as well as its guests.



      I'm glad I could write something that strikes a chord with what people in the capital think. I wish it hits the people of the whole nation.

      cheers!

      Delete
  2. Very well structured... Beautifully put.
    'The author' here in this write up looks touched by the facts of whats happening in the capital.
    Also she uses facts very aptly to put in a few points straight to the readers.

    My view:-
    I agree that NE is not given its due in terms of what is deserves, but rape and violence are a matter of greater concern and is something that is not limited to them, we may call it a racist attack but I believe that law and order should be such that even if some foreign individual is in THE CAPITAL of India, (s)he should feel safe.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. i agree with your view but my concern is that when people like me and you call africans as "niggers" and northeasterners as "chinki", it reflects the fallacies in our personalities and a fault in our upbringing. When Sharukh Khan is frisked at the JFK international airport, it turns out into a diplomatic crisis and we personally condemn America but when we ourselves do such things, we don't feel a tinge of remorse.

      law and order is yes, indeed a huge problem but just because the elephant is huge, doesn't mean we ignore the crocodile! Racism reflects the attitude of people like us!

      If we as people of Delhi, are insecure while stepping out at night, just imagine the plight of those Indians who just dont merely look like us.

      Delete
    2. Thanks for the comment. I'm glad I could put forward some new facts etc.

      Delete
  3. Your views are very articulative and have been backed up by relevant current issues and data figures but I would like to say that WOMEN in general are eyed differently in our patriarchal society as if we were born to understand discrimination towards us and as if we should abide by the "so called traditions" which have been custom made by men to prove their superiority and we have been following them blindly without questioning them even once till of late! So yes, judiciary and the executive should work coherenty to make women from all the places (including Delhi) safe in the city, not to mention that Delhi is as much home to the non-Delhiites too as it is to Delhiites! Law and order situation in the Capital of Indial is abysmal and needs to be improved where a person from any Taluk of India and a foreigner would be heard just like an ordinary human being. BEING HUMAN is what we need the most. That said, I would like to quote Gilles Deleuze, a French philosopher - "It is better to be a schizophrenic out for a walk than a neurotic on a couch." i.e. it is better if we be comfortable with our multiple identities if we are not to collapse into the neurosis of the singular if we have to maintain the diversity of India.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. like i said above, law and order is a larger problem and the north east problems and women problems are their subset. Why should we expect the girls from NorthEast to change their dressing sense after all? If women of the capital are not safe even after covering themselves from head to toe, the north east girls have double insecurity.

      attitude change!!! is a must!!
      law and order is not in our hands but a transformation in the mindset of the people through mass mobilization is something we can try to bring about, starting from ourselves and our families.

      being human! being Indian!

      Delete